Bentonville converted all of its penalty-kick attempts, while Evan Shanks provided the needed block as the Tigers edged Rogers.

hanks denied Fransisco Jimenez of a score on Rogers' second penalty-kick attempt. The Tigers (7-2, 4-1) made it count as Rodrigo Mouron, Johnny Merlos, Ryan Fox, Andrew Wagner and Bryce Mills are were successful on their shootout attempts, while Trey Keith, Esteban Chavez and Brayan Flores scored for Rogers (5-4-2, 2-3).

The teams battled to a 2-2 halftime deadlock as Jimenez and Saldiema provided Rogers' goals, while Thomas Borenholtz and Mouron scored for Bentonville. Mouron scored again with 36:47 remaining to give the Tigers a 3-2 lead, only to have Chavez tie it 2 minutes later.